Subscribe to The Game Within the Game
9 days to MLB Draft
10 days to MLB Home Run Derby
11 days to MLB All-Star Game
23 days to Baseball Hall of Fame Induction Weekend
27 days to MLB Trade Deadline
forty4 Baseball
forty4 Baseball
San Diego's Losing Streak Isn't a Surprise. The Numbers Called It.

San Diego's Losing Streak Isn't a Surprise. The Numbers Called It.

San Diego has lost six straight and been outscored badly along the way, but forty4 Baseball's Behind the Box Score data shows the warning signs were already there: a top-three overperformance gap the week before. An offensive collapse and an injured reliever explain why the correction landed so hard.

San Diego has dropped six straight, and the shape of the skid makes it hard to call a fluke. The Padres were run off the field 23-3 by the Cubs during the streak, and they enter the weekend a dozen games back of the Dodgers in the NL West. What makes this stretch notable is not merely that it happened, but that forty4 Baseball's own data flagged the conditions for it more than a week before the streak started.

The six losses have come against a mix of contenders and fellow strugglers alike, which is part of what makes the pattern hard to write off as one bad matchup. San Diego dropped two of three to the Cardinals before the Cubs series turned into a rout, then opened a series against the division-leading Dodgers with another loss. A stretch spread across that many different opponents points toward something systemic rather than a single hot pitching staff getting in the way.

What forty4 Baseball's Data Already Flagged

Our Behind the Box Score report, published June 29 and covering the week of June 22 through June 28, showed San Diego posting a plus-1.3 gap between its actual record and its Pythagorean-expected record — the third-largest overperformance gap in the sport that week. In plain terms, the Padres were winning more games than their underlying run-scoring and run-prevention numbers supported. That kind of gap tends to close one of two ways: either the process catches up to the results, or the results fall back to meet the process. San Diego's current losing streak looks like the latter.

It's worth being direct about what today's other reports showed and didn't. forty4 Baseball's Double Take report had no ERA-versus-WHIP mismatches or other stat-line anomalies clear the bar today — every category came back empty. The Hot & Cold tracker, by contrast, is live and current as of this morning, and San Diego's six-game skid sits alongside a Tampa Bay eight-game win streak and a New York seven-game slide as the most notable team trends in baseball right now. Those other two threads are already the subject of forty4 Baseball's own recent coverage, which is why this piece follows the Padres instead.

Where the Offense Went

The run differential problem traces to the lineup, not the pitching staff. San Diego entered this stretch ranked 27th in the majors in OPS at .667, and the trio expected to carry the offense — Manny Machado, Fernando Tatis Jr., and Jackson Merrill — had combined for a .641 OPS with just 10 home runs between them. Machado summed it up plainly: the team simply isn't hitting. Tatis, normally the offense's engine, has been part of the slump rather than an escape from it, and Merrill's power has gone quiet at the same time Machado's has. When the top of the order stalls together, there is no complementary bat underneath it to lean on. A four-game series against the Cardinals produced only 14 hits, the fewest San Diego has managed in a four-game set all season, and the Padres still needed their pitching staff to steal two wins out of it.

That pitching staff has carried an outsized share of the load all year, which made the loss of setup reliever Jason Adam to a shoulder strain especially costly. Adam landed on the 15-day injured list retroactive to June 30, right as the bullpen needed to cover for an offense that had gone cold. Germán Márquez has returned from his own injured list stint to help fill the gap, but losing a trusted late-inning arm during a losing streak tends to compound the problem rather than solve it.

What Comes Next for the Padres

A plus-1.3 overperformance gap and a six-game losing streak don't cancel each other out cleanly — San Diego was a good team playing slightly better than its numbers justified, and now it's a good team playing worse than its numbers probably justify in the other direction. The truer read likely sits somewhere in between. Twelve games back with the trade deadline approaching, the front office now has to decide whether this is a lineup that needs reinforcements or one that needs time for its established hitters to look like themselves again. San Diego's front office has rarely stood pat at the deadline in recent seasons, and a slide like this one tends to accelerate difficult roster conversations rather than delay them.

Behind the Box Score exists to catch exactly this kind of gap before the standings fully reflect it. This week, the numbers got there first.

More from forty4 Baseball

Pour That Coffee Slow, Last Night's Baseball Earned It

Pour That Coffee Slow, Last Night's Baseball Earned It

Los Angeles overcame a six-run deficit to beat San Diego 12-7 in the night's headline comeback. The Cardinals rallied past Atlanta with a seven-run seventh, the Rays swept Kansas City for an eighth straight win, and Cleveland walked off Chicago on Brayan Rocchio's ninth-inning home run in a tightening AL Central race.
read more »
Detroit's Run Differential Says They Should Be Winning, Too. Their Bullpen Says Otherwise.

Detroit's Run Differential Says They Should Be Winning, Too. Their Bullpen Says Otherwise.

forty4 Baseball's daily team-trends data shows the Detroit Tigers carrying the widest gap between actual and expected wins in baseball. They outscored Houston in late June and still lost games, a pattern that traces back to a bullpen that has blown more late leads than any other team in MLB this season.
read more »
Pour the Coffee: Dansby Swanson Just Rewrote Cubs History

Pour the Coffee: Dansby Swanson Just Rewrote Cubs History

The Chicago Cubs' 23-3 demolition of the Padres, headlined by Dansby Swanson's historic three-homer, eight-RBI night, leads a wild Wednesday across baseball that also saw the Detroit Tigers complete a sweep of the Yankees in extra innings and New York's losing streak stretch to seven straight games.
read more »