Subscribe to The Game Within the Game
7 days to MLB Draft
8 days to MLB Home Run Derby
9 days to MLB All-Star Game
21 days to Baseball Hall of Fame Induction Weekend
25 days to MLB Trade Deadline
forty4 Baseball
forty4 Baseball
How Can the Mets Be This Bad and This Good?

How Can the Mets Be This Bad and This Good?

A 3-game skid and a brutal week in June put the Mets near the bottom of MLB's run differential rankings and cost their manager his job. But forty4 Baseball's Hot & Cold and Double Take data reveal a dominant bullpen streak and a starter getting unlucky, both buried in the same clubhouse producing all the losses.

Three losses in a row does not sound like news in Queens this summer. Neither does another shaky night from the rotation. But sitting inside the same stretch of box scores that keeps pushing the Mets toward the bottom of the NL East is one of the more genuinely dominant streaks in baseball, and forty4 Baseball's cross-report data shows both things are true at the exact same time.

A Week That Confirms the Standings

The Mets enter July on a 3-game losing streak, one of five active skids of three games or longer across the league. That is the present tense. The recent past is worse. Over the week of June 22 through June 28, forty4 Baseball's Behind the Box Score data has New York at 1-6, with 28 runs scored against 42 allowed — a run differential of -14, ahead of only Kansas City for worst in the majors. The math says that week should have produced roughly 2.2 wins. It produced one, a gap of -1.1 that puts the Mets among the more notable underperformers in the sport. That stretch also covers the date the Mets fired manager Carlos Mendoza, handing the club to interim manager Andy Green, and the early moves of what looks like a sell-off, with left-hander David Peterson already dealt to the Chicago Cubs. None of this is a surprise to anyone who has watched the Mets this year. What is more surprising is what is happening on the mound at the same time.

The One Arm Nobody Can Touch

forty4 Baseball's Hot & Cold report has reliever Luke Weaver riding a 15 consecutive scoreless outing streak, second in the majors behind only Philadelphia's Jhoan Duran. External coverage this week has told a version of the same story with a bigger number attached, with national and Mets beat reporting placing Weaver's active run in the low twenties depending on when the count was taken. The gap is worth flagging rather than smoothing over — it likely comes down to differences in how relief appearances get logged — but forty4 Baseball's own tracking is the number driving this piece, and the direction is not in question either way. A pitcher who opened the season with an ERA over seven has not allowed a run since spring turned to summer. That turnaround has made Weaver, by outside accounts, one of the more attractive trade chips on a roster that is otherwise being stripped for parts ahead of the deadline.

A Pitcher Whose Ledger Does Not Match His Stuff

Weaver is not the only arm whose numbers tell a better story than the record does. forty4 Baseball's Double Take report flags right-hander Nolan McLean with a 3.78 ERA against a .205 opponent batting average, one of the widest gaps in the sport between how rarely hitters make contact against him and what his earned run average implies. That is a sequencing story more than a stuff story. Hitters are barely reaching base against McLean, and the runs are finding a way to score anyway, whether through timing, bullpen support, or simple bad luck with runners in scoring position. It lines up with what has been visible on the field lately, including a career-high strikeout total in whiffs during a recent six-inning outing. The stuff grades out well beyond what the earned run average suggests, which is the entire point of a report built to catch exactly this kind of mismatch.

The Other End of the Rotation

Every version of good news on this pitching staff has a counterweight, and it belongs to Sean Manaea. forty4 Baseball's Hot & Cold data has Manaea in the middle of a 9-game streak of allowing at least one run in every outing, tied for the longest active streak of its kind in the majors alongside Pittsburgh's Mitch Keller and Braxton Ashcraft. Manaea signed a three-year, $75 million contract last offseason and looked like the rotation's steadying influence after returning to a starting role in mid-June, only to cool off in the weeks since. The same clubhouse producing one of the best bullpen streaks in the sport is also producing one of the longest runs-allowed streaks among starters, and the two are happening in parallel rather than in sequence.

None of this changes what the standings say about the Mets right now, and it should not. A 3-game losing streak sitting on top of a week that was worse than its own run differential is real, and so is a front office that has already started selling. But the numbers underneath that record describe a roster that is uneven rather than uniformly struggling, with a shutdown reliever, an unlucky starter, and a cooling veteran all wearing the same uniform in the same month. That unevenness, more than the losing streak itself, is likely what shapes the next few weeks in Queens.

More from forty4 Baseball

Your Morning Coffee Just Got a Central Division Jolt

Your Morning Coffee Just Got a Central Division Jolt

The AL Central is now a dead heat after Chicago beat Cleveland, San Diego's skid reaches eight straight in a Dodgers shutout, Atlanta blew past the Mets, and Milwaukee dropped one in Arizona but kept its six-game cushion. A full look at every score, plus what to watch as tomorrow's games get underway.
read more »
The Phillies Keep Winning Close Games. Their Closer Is Why.

The Phillies Keep Winning Close Games. Their Closer Is Why.

Philadelphia has climbed within three games of first place in the NL East, and forty4 Baseball's data shows why. Jhoan Duran's 16-outing scoreless streak lines up with the Phillies' positive Pythagorean gap for the week of June 22-28, pointing to a rebuilt bullpen behind the team's recent surge into contention.
read more »
San Diego's Losing Streak Isn't a Surprise. The Numbers Called It.

San Diego's Losing Streak Isn't a Surprise. The Numbers Called It.

San Diego has lost six straight and been outscored badly along the way, but forty4 Baseball's Behind the Box Score data shows the warning signs were already there: a top-three overperformance gap the week before. An offensive collapse and an injured reliever explain why the correction landed so hard.
read more »